About Us How to file a complaint Outcomes of past hearings Speaker Services Education Program Newsworthy Magazine Newsworthy TV Series Events Ethics Resources Sponsor Lists

HEARING INDEX: CRIME COVERAGE
Complaint Hearing #
Year
Decision Media Description
Aggressive reporting endangers victim

#11

1974

Upheld Minneapolis Tribune Paper endangered life of kidnap victim when it assigned reporter to follow course of ransom drops
Unnecessarily publishing name of victim

#49

1983

Not Upheld* Star Tribune Grievant says it was cruel and unnecessary to publish names and cities of residence of vulnerable and elderly victims of a swindle, causing them further humiliation
Improperly divulging name of crime witness

#70

1987

Upheld* Owatonna People's Press Witness to an assault identified though assailant was still at-large and despite her request for anonymity
Students named in alcohol offense

#73

1988

Not Upheld St. Cloud Times Parent complained that the names of juveniles suspended from sports team for drinking should not have been mentioned in sports article
Sensationalized report of illegal activity and reporter breaking law to get story

#74

1988

Not Upheld* WCCO-TV Burlington Northern complained that human interest story of business exec who liked to "ride rails" promoted illegal activity and reporter engaged in same illegal activity to get story
Television station actions unethical

#98

1993

Upheld*


Upheld


Not Upheld

KARE-TV

• Unethically transported a murder suspect without informing police, thus putting officers at risk, and did not inform hired airline pilot of risk
• Interfered with woman under protective custody
• Contributed to "circus" environment during surrender of a serial rape suspect

Invaded privacy of juvenile incest victim

#106

1993

Upheld Wabasha County Herald Small town girl, a victim of incest, complained that newspaper revictimized her when it identified her and detailed the crimes committed against her when reporting on the sentencing of her father.
Unfair to report only one side of a sexual harassment case that was settled out of court with a non-disclosure agreement  #125 Upheld Savage Pacer Mayoral candidate says paper was unfair to cover story of sexual harassment charges brought against him but settled out of court because he cannot comment on it to defend himself.

 

 

 

 

KEY

U: Upheld

N: Not upheld

U/N: Aspects upheld, others not upheld

--: Unable to rule on an issue

*: written dissenting opinion on file