About Us How to file a complaint Outcomes of past hearings Speaker Services Education Program Newsworthy Magazine Newsworthy TV Series Events Ethics Resources Sponsor Lists

HEARING INDEX: MISCELLANEOUS
Complaint Hearing #
Year
Decision Media Description
Special issues of newspaper

#14

1975

N St. Paul Pioneer Press MFT argues that special newspaper facsimile edition disclaimer was too small and easily overlooked, causing paper to be misleading
Journalistic standards

#17

1975

U Ely Echo v. Ely Miner Two feuding small-town papers charge each other with unprofessional behavior
Journalistic standards

#24

1977

U Brainerd Daily Tribune Dentists in fluoridation debate charge paper with failure to maintain journalistic standards
Journalistic standards

#45

1982

U Proctor Journal City council charges that paper exceeded bounds of journalistic propriety in attacking personal integrity of council members
Offensive language

#78

1989

U Minneapolis Spokesman Police officer objects to being called "Chief Bouza's boy"
Journalistic practice on use of all caps

#80

1990

U* West Central Tribune Cooperative school district complains that paper refuses to correctly capitalize its name (MACCRAY)
Undue prominence to Christian doctrine

#84

1990

N Tri-County Record Reader objects to weekly religion page that is predominantly Christian
Unethical use of hidden camera

#101

1994

U* KSTP-TV The Minnesota Dept of Health alleges that an investigative reporter used a hidden camera to get soundbites of employees in private conversation questioning spending money on retreat and broadcast them without employees knowledge or consent
Unethically used an undercover reporter, relied uncritically upon opinions of critic

105

1995

N*/N*

Star Tribune

• Women's studies Department charged paper committed an ethical violation by using an undercover reporter/student in a classroom and mischaracterizing the story it was working on,
that they relied uncritically upon the works of a "right wing" critic and didn't ask for comment from national sources

Misleading video footage; conclusions not justified by evidence

 121

1999

U

U

KSTP-TV DNR complained that television series misled viewers when it showed footage of vacationers (not DNR employees) at a resort and showed summer footage when describing meetings that took place other times of the year
Unethical use of hidden camera, invasion of privacy 126 (tied vote) WCCO-TV Nursing home administrator complained that TV used hidden camera and taped a nursing home resident without family permission.
Glorification of violence

148

2007

N Ely Echo Principal, superintendent complained that picture of children dressed as "dead superintendent" & "principal killer" was irresponsible

 

 

 

 

KEY

U: Upheld

N: Not upheld

U/N: Aspects upheld, others not upheld

--: Unable to rule on an issue

*: written dissenting opinion on file